Poetry
Winning Piece
Collateral
Ali Darwiche
Before me sits a woman
with a lifetime folded somewhere inside her.
There are years within her
that I will never know—
kitchens warmed by voices,
hands that held children,
names she once carried easily
on the surface of her tongue.
But now the new days slip through her hands.
Some memories remain.
Some loosen.
Some leave quietly.
I speak to her son on the phone,
and his voice carries what hers cannot.
He tells me how quickly she has changed,
how the woman who once remembered for everyone
now needs others to remember for her.
In medicine, we call this collateral:
the history gathered beside the patient,
the story medicine asks for
when the mind can no longer give it whole.
But as I listen,
I begin to wonder
who will one day speak for me.
Where will I be
when time begins to take inventory
of what I can still hold?
Will I remember the olive trees in Lebanon,
their silver leaves turning in the sun,
their branches rooted in a soil
that feels older than language?
Will I remember the taste of home,
the way one place can live inside you
even after you have crossed oceans?
Will I remember Zaytoon,
my cat named after that olive,
a small reminder of where I come from?
And will there come a day
when familiar faces approach me
as strangers?
If that day comes,
I pray I have people beside me
who do not mistake my forgetting
for emptiness.
I pray they bring photographs.
I pray they tell me stories.
I pray they say,
Here you are, running beneath the olive trees.
Here you are, laughing with us.
Here you are, holding Zaytoon close.
Here you are, standing beside a patient,
learning that medicine is not only
the study of what fails in the body,
but the practice of protecting
what remains of a person.
Here you are, listening and serving.
Here you are, dear.
And I pray I am kind to them.
I pray that even if my memories are damaged,
my tenderness is not.
Maybe this is what collateral really means:
not merely a history taken from someone else,
not merely a son’s voice over the phone,
not merely the facts written down
when the patient cannot testify alone.
Maybe collateral is what remains
when memory becomes too fragile
to carry a life by itself.
The people who love us
become the keepers of our remembering.
So perhaps this is what we should strive for:
to live a life worth holding,
worth retelling,
worth protecting in the minds of others—
so that even if one day
we cannot find ourselves,
someone who loves us
can still point gently and say,
There you are, dear.
Author: Ali Darwiche
Bio: Ali Darwiche is a fourth-year medical student at the University of Michigan Medical School who is pursuing a career in psychiatry. Prior to medical school, he served as a health educator at ACCESS, the largest Arab American non-profit social service agency in the United States. His time there deeply rooted him in the power of community mental health, storytelling, and advocacy, which continues to shape his approach to patient care and humanism in medicine.
Commentary: “Collateral” grew out of my geriatric psychiatry rotation, where I saw how often loved ones help tell a patient’s story when memory can no longer do it alone. Watching a son describe who his mother had been made me reflect on more than cognitive decline. It made me wonder what remains of us when our own minds can no longer hold our memories.
The poem asks whether a person’s life, identity, and meaning end there—or whether they can be carried forward through the people who love them. By drawing on memories of Lebanon and my cat, Zaytoon, I tried to connect that question to my own sense of home and self. Ultimately, the piece reflects on medicine as not only caring for what is lost, but also recognizing and protecting what remains.